Pelham Bakery is a welcoming destination in Pelham, NY, where quality baked goods, friendly service, and everyday convenience come together to create a memorable experience.
As both a bakery and cake shop, it brings customers the comfort of freshly prepared treats and the satisfaction of knowing they can count on a trusted local business for everything from a quick stop-in to a special occasion order.
Whether you are looking for a delicious pastry, a custom cake, or simply a place to enjoy a cup of coffee, Pelham Bakery offers the kind of warm, neighborhood atmosphere that keeps customers coming back.
Convenience is part of what makes Pelham Bakery such a valued choice. With on-site service, takeaway, and delivery options, it is designed to fit easily into busy routines while still delivering the quality and care customers expect.
The bakery is ideal for a quick visit, making it a convenient stop for morning coffee, an afternoon treat, or a last-minute dessert solution.
Located at 121 Fifth Ave, Pelham, NY 10803, United States, it is easy to find and simple to access, whether you are picking up something special or arranging delivery for home, work, or an event.
Customer satisfaction speaks for itself, with Pelham Bakery earning an impressive 4.80 out of 5 rating based on 56 reviews. That strong reputation reflects the bakery’s commitment to dependable service, delicious offerings, and a consistently positive experience.
For anyone seeking a bakery and cake shop that combines quality, convenience, and a welcoming touch, Pelham Bakery stands out as a trusted local favorite. Call +1 914-738-0804 to learn more about the offerings and discover why so many customers choose Pelham Bakery.
Our Specialties
Every dish tells a story. Explore our carefully curated menu featuring seasonal favorites and signature creations.
Our chef's signature creations featuring locally-sourced ingredients and innovative culinary techniques.
We partner with local farmers and suppliers to bring you the freshest seasonal ingredients every day.
Every plate is prepared with attention to detail, combining traditional recipes with modern presentation.
Our Story
Welcome to a place where great food meets warm hospitality. We believe dining is more than just a meal - it's an experience to be savored and shared.
Our kitchen is dedicated to creating dishes that bring people together, using recipes that honor tradition while embracing innovation.
Photos
A glimpse of our restaurant experience
Hear from our valued guests
Traditional family bakery store. Paul is always kind and works very hard to offer a variety of delicious items. He's made cookies custom order and wrapped for me for my child's class and it came out wonderful. Support local! Shop has much nostalgia feeling.
An authentic, old school bakery. Delicious cookies, great custom order cakes, and fantastic pastries ( eclairs, napoleons, and tarts). As good as anything I’ve had in the five boroughs. This is a friendly, family owned business. It’s heart warming to go in on the holidays and see lines of people ordering for family dinners and events. They even have spools of string hanging down from the ceiling to tie up your special treats! Highly recommended.
It is the old school bakery in Pelham. The cannoli, cannoli cake, and raspberry butter cookies are excellent. This place is totally unpretentious.
I order a Cannoli cake an cookies an extra cannolis they where delicious I will definitely return to the bakery for other yummy desserts an store smell like heaven
This is an old school bakery the way they're supposed to be. Black and white cookie was fantastic and so was the cherry pie. Cash only folks cash only. That's fine. That's what I expected. Will definitely be going back.
Delicious baked goods. Kind proprietor. A special place for sweets.
Old fashioned bakery, you don’t find these anymore. I’m a big fan of baked goods so had to stop in once I realized how close I work to this bakery. The owner was very friendly, the atmosphere was great, very homey feel, just good vibe all around. I ordered a lb of cookies, rainbow cookies and a linzer tart. Everything was fresh, soft, perfection. Not too sweet like a lot of other Italian cookies.. everything was just perfect!! So happy to have found this place!!
Amazing selection of cookies! A lot of custom handmade cakes. Everything delicious! Def a place to go when I am in town!
I stopped in recently to pick up a very last minute cake for a birthday celebration, no pre order made. There were so many choices. I picked up a small strawberry shortcake (made with fresh strawberries) and it was a huge hit! Like other reviews mention, this is an “old school bakery” vibe, no frills, just a large variety of home made delicious treats and reasonably priced. I’d highly recommend to anyone in the area in need of a special order dessert, last minute needs, or just something really yummy to enjoy! ***cash only
The bakery feels like a wonderful flash from the past — exactly how classic bakeries used to look. We tried the cannolis and were absolutely amazed. The cream was incredibly fresh, perfectly balanced with a crispy shell on the outside. Everything tasted authentic and made with care. We’ll definitely be stopping by again whenever we’re in the area.
Common questions about Pelham Bakery
Pelham Bakery is located at 121 Fifth Ave, Pelham, NY 10803, United States, Pelham, NY, United States.
You can reach Pelham Bakery by calling +1 914-738-0804.
Pelham Bakery has a rating of 4.8 out of 5 based on 56 customer reviews.
Pelham Bakery features the following service options: On-site services, Takeaway, Delivery.
Pelham Bakery features the following offerings: Coffee.
Pelham Bakery features the following planning: Quick visit.
Business Features
We look forward to welcoming you. Make a reservation or stop by - walk-ins welcome!
Request a table and we'll confirm your booking shortly.
